• Our Blogger

    Fr. Joseph Jenkins

  • The blog header depicts an important and yet mis-understood New Testament scene, Jesus flogging the money-changers out of the temple. I selected it because the faith that gives us consolation can also make us very uncomfortable. Both Divine Mercy and Divine Justice meet in Jesus. Priests are ministers of reconciliation, but never at the cost of truth. In or out of season, we must be courageous in preaching and living out the Gospel of Life. The title of my blog is a play on words, not Flogger Priest but Blogger Priest.

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Recent Posts

  • Recent Comments

    Barbara King's avatarBarbara King on Ask a Priest
    Ben Kirk's avatarBen Kirk on Ask a Priest
    Jeremy Kok's avatarJeremy Kok on Ask a Priest
    Barbara's avatarBarbara on Ask a Priest
    forsamuraimarket's avatarforsamuraimarket on Ask a Priest

Priestly Celibacy – A Wasted or Fulfilled Life?

I have heard the challenge to celibacy that it is not natural. This is, of course, quite absurd. Like marriage, it is perfectly within the range of properly oriented human conduct; although, it represents (in perpetuity) a road less traveled. What is sometimes at force in such charges is not any appreciation for natural law, because these same accusers might lobby on behalf of homosexuality, but rather a form of atheism. We all know that even self-acclaimed believers sometimes live as if there is no God. While they might temporarily support the “new celibacy” that abstains from sex and relationships for the sake of upward mobility and a business career; they resoundingly object to “Christian celibacy” that sets aside earthly pleasure and companionship for spiritual treasure and intimacy with God. We hear this mentality in slogans like, “Go for the gusto!” and “You only live once, so make the most of it!” Especially when a priest fails to keep up with his prayer life, he becomes subject to this attack. “Where is God? Does it matter that I have given up the chance to have a wife and children? Have I wasted my life?”

When I first started my seminary studies, it was with the Franciscan TORs. We lived at the seminary and commuted down the hill to their adjacent college, now Saint Francis University in Loretto, PA. The young brothers had an interesting sense of humor and a few sang a made-up song on the bus one day that both shocked and amused me. We were all philosophy students and I guess the upper classmen were studying atheism. I still remember the refrain of their ditty, “Sorry, there is no God, you left your girlfriend for nothing.” If non-believers were right, the song brought home the absurdity of what we were about…forsaking a wife and family, all so that we might spread the cult of an imaginary deity. Of course, I am personally convinced that the atheists are in the wrong and for this there will be eternal consequences.

6 Responses

  1. Father Joe

    When are you going to write an apologetics book on Catholicism?

  2. Father Joe – thanks for the adjustment.

    Maisie – you are bullying Father Joe out of the great wealth of your own lack of faith, spiritual sickness, resulting lack of charity, and true ignorance of the topic about which you write. You really need God in your life to heal you – He is present, but certainly not in you; if you find the strength to be humble and docile toward God and His servants, then He will begin to heal you. But He is not going to help you if you are beating His servants as you do in your words.. Deep down, you are hurting, too. Open the Bible and read and learn about what Jesus Christ (True God and True Man) taught, what He expects of you, what you have not done or do not do in disobedience to God and the Natural Law (that Law which is written in our hearts, but which we sometimes ignore to our own detriment) and then open your heart to God for healing. If your soul is damaged, then your whole body and whole life will be damaged. See? God can and will heal your soul if you allow it.

  3. I actually enjoyed your original post. Not everyone is critical all of the time. 🙂

  4. Father Joe – I meant [the word “doctor”] in a charitable and respectful way – that you are indeed a “doctor” of souls in the work that you do. As such, having “treated” many people with spiritual ills, and being an expert at that, you could be called “doctor” in a metaphorical way because you, indeed, are like a doctor.

    When I write something to you, please try to see me as a person with charitable intent toward you – as I am. Thank you, and thank you for your answer.

    FATHER JOE: You should see the comments that are not posted from others. It weighs on one. I have adjusted both your comment and changed mine. Peace!

  5. Priest, you are full of [expletive deleted]. You geeks are just afraid of sex. Grow up and find yourself a woman or man, depending on which way you go. Take care of people and be nice. Stop judging others. You have no right. I am bi- and live with my husband and wife. We are happy but you probably think we are going to hell. There may be a god or goddess, but I cannot believe in yours. Guess what? You have wasted your life, and all for a lie! At least the married priests have something to show for there lives. You have nothing. Nobody cares, get it? You could be [expletive deleted] on the side and no one would care. Just play some good music, tell a joke or nice story on the weekends, and help people. That is enough! You are pathetic. And now you go on and on trying to rationalize what cannot be defended. You are a woman-hater and afraid. You have nothing. You are nothing. You are just a fat old man who found out too late that he ruined his life. Stop trying to ruin the lives of others. They can still be happy and satisfied. Blessed be!

    FATHER JOE: Maisie, you are wrong about many things but your post is representative of the very problem which I have tried to address. Were you raised a Catholic? The Wicca blessing did not pass by me. Are you into the occult? Prayers for all who think like you!

  6. Well, but what sort of wounds might make an atheist into an atheist dear doctor?

    FATHER JOE

    Today is the memorial for Saint Alphonsus Liguouri, a doctor of the Church. You really need to save your “doctor” label for those who deserve it. I am nothing but a poor priest trying to see through the fog.

    First, in answer to your question, faith is a mysterious gift of the Holy Spirit. Siblings can have the same upbringing and religious education and yet one might become a priest and the other might drop away from religious observance entirely, dismissing the very notion of a deity. Second, while some people of faith grow stronger and more devout because of challenges, others respond in a contrary manner.

    People might feel that God is not listening to their prayers and is absent and does not care.

    People might be swayed by certain scientists and the “new atheism” which regards religion as dangerous myth.

    People might experience great losses or fail to discern signs of God’s goodness and activity in the world.

    People might become discouraged by hypocrisy in the Church and the scandals of the day.

    People might become “practical” atheists, going through the motions of faith to appease family or out of an empty sense of duty, but not really placing much store in anything supernatural.

    People might reject the moral teachings of the faith (contraception, abortion, euthanasia, fornication, adultery, homosexuality, etc.) and having such truth claims undermined, dismiss God along with the Church.

    People might have a gradual incursion into atheism, not rejecting God out rightly but dismissing claims of divine intervention like original sin and baptismal regeneration, priestly power of absolution, the Eucharistic real presence, miracles, etc.

    Those who go through the motions or who harbor serious doubts would view priestly celibacy as rather absurd. Those who assert that politicians and lawyers can arbitrarily “legislate” morality, believe that we can change whatever we want to change, dismissing any divine prerogative.

    Some regard religion as an important force for social justice, especially on matters like care for the poor, fighting the death penalty and saving the environment. The recent conflict with the Obama administration was a conflict precisely upon this point. His administration took it upon itself to define what constituted the Church, reducing the faith to an arm of the HHS. Even Christ is defined much as a grassroots civil rights activist and/or motivational speaker. Such is a far cry from a Jesus who is Lord and God. There are Catholics who accept such a shallow bankrupt view of the Church and the Lord. They would judge celibacy as surrendering an opportunity for natural fulfillment for something they would deem insubstantial or nebulous or unreal. This has even infected our view of the afterlife.

    Many Catholics today do not pray for the dead. They do not ask for sanctoral intercession. You hear what they believe in eulogies, “At least Uncle Fred will live on in our memories.” That’s it, but there is a problem. We are going to die, too. Who will remember us, let alone, Uncle Fred? I even had a funeral where the atheists in the crowd objected to my presence. The diseased man’s son, made me wait over an hour to say a prayer, and once I had offered my remarks, he immediately took over the service at the funeral parlor and said, “And now for the rest of us who do not believe the fairytale about life after death….” The director of the funeral parlor apologized to me. We kept our cool. It was no place for debate. But I added them to my prayer list and still remember them, years later.

    Have to go now, I have a parishioner who is 103 and she needs her priest. Peace!

Leave a comment