Feel free to submit a new question or concern in the comment box below. Various topics and questions are archived here for easy retrieval. Please be courteous. Comments are moderated so please be patient in waiting for them to appear and for any responses. God bless you!
NEW MESSAGES/HOMILIES CHRISTIAN REFLECTIONS DEFENDING THE FAITH















































Father,
Can one disagree with the Church’s teachings on same-sex marriage and still be a Catholic Priest?
Hello,
Just found this page. I like it. I have many questions to ask if I don’t find the answers from the blogs here. Thank you for this site.
Thank you, Father! That really helps.
Father,
This is a question about vocation. About six months ago, I was working in the same job I am working in now, but I felt very lost. At lunch, I said a prayer, and I asked God to show me what he wants me to do. Before I left work for the day, I ran into the CEO of our company, and, long story short, he extended an offer to pay for graduate school. After fulfilling all the requirements, I am now ready to begin classes this fall; however, I am still experiencing some uneasiness about making the right choice. My question is: is this fear a sign that I did not do the right thing or is the fear my distrust in the path God has for me?
Hello, Father! Thank you for taking the time to answer so many questions. I typically find your Q & As pretty spiritually nourishing.
Anyway, my question involves my father, who passed away nearly 14 years ago. He was born and raised into the Reformed Protestant church, and while he was a faithful and sincere Christian, he had never been baptized (he had always assumed that he had been baptized as an infant, and only discovered that he indeed had not late in his life).
When he and my mother (who is a practicing Catholic) wed, he agreed to raise me in the Catholic religion–a promise he fulfilled quite wonderfully, I am so happy to tell. He strongly desired to be baptized, but he struggled so hard to discern whether the Catholic religion is truly the Church founded by Christ, or if he should be baptized by a Reformed Protestant minister. He struggled with this for years. What turned out to be just a few days before he death, he asked to be baptized Catholic. And he was! On his deathbed! He died mere moments after his baptism–certainly he committed no sin after receiving the sacrament. His funeral Mass was attended by more than a hundred people, and it was concelebrated by 4–FOUR!–priests, including a Monsignor. He had seminarians serving alongside about a half a dozen alter servers, and an entire choir singing. Not bad for a lifelong Protestant!
Sister Columbine, a downright saintly nun at our parish, told me with downright glee that my dad “stole Heaven” by virtue of his deathbed conversion and baptism–a sacrament, I understand, washes away all sin AND all temporal punishment. For that reason, I have never had any masses offered for his soul, nor have I ever prayed for his release from Purgatory. (Though I will request masses for a general “deceased members of the so-and-so family.”) All of which gives me a very uneasy feeling. Am I (profoundly) neglecting my father by not having masses offered for his? Or would I be denying Church teaching on Baptism by doing so?
Thank you for taking the time to read my question. I look forward to reading your advice!
Dear Fr. Joe, First of all, thank you for this ministry you have of answering questions. I’m a 43 yr. old homeschooling mom. My husband and I have 6 children (one on the way) and we’re both recent converts to Catholicism. My question is: Is it sinful to consciously distance myself from the family I was born into (not initiate phone calls or invitations to visit, not visit them, etc..?) I’ve always been the “peacemaking bridge-builder” of my family, keeping in touch despite growing differences between my own family and those of my 3 siblings and my parents, who are in their 80’s and divorced. But I’m tired of it. My siblings and parents are secular, judgmental and quite selfish people (of course now I sound judgmental…) and other than returning a phone call to be polite, I just want to forget making contact with them. These family ties are not good for me or my own family. Thank you, Father.
Hello,
If you believe that Christ died for everyone’s sins, why would someone need to be baptized? Is the baptism of someone outside the Catholic church valid as far as you are concerned. i.e. Protestant?
Thanks, D. Straus
Thank you for your quick response….but can u also explain to me exactly what the blasphemy against the Holy Spirit is?
FATHER JOE: Blasphemy against the Holy Spirit is ascribing any work of God to the demonic.
Dear Father, a Catholic recently told me that not fasting on Fridays is grave matter. I am a practicing catholic, but I find that hard to believe: it seems to me that there are so many more important things in life to worry about, like raising your children, loving your wife, going to Church on Sundays and praying regularly etc… and Catholics should not get too hung up on “small details” like this. What do you think? Thank you!
Recently while I was at church singing a church song, I accidentally sang the wrong thing. I was supposed to sing ‘undeserving thats what we are’ and instead I sang ‘ undeserving thats who you are’. So, I accidentally called God undeserving. Does this mean that I have blasphemed the Holy Ghost? Please reply to my email address with explanation.
Thanks much.
Hi I’m not here to joke about I’m being serious, I was wondering if I had a succubus would there be anyway my church would be able to help me get rid of this demon. I have been christened and I do believe I’m god please answer thank you.
Thank you for your response to my question about a Josephite marriage below. A follow-up question to clarify: My understanding is that for a valid marriage a couple must commit to fidelity, indissolubility, and openness to children.
I was confused as to why a Josephite marriage could be valid because it is missing one of the “pillars?” Does it require a dispensation? Are the vows altered to not include openness to children? As well, is it always open to be annulled because the marriage was never consummated?
I appreciate these are rare instances. I also appreciate the beauty of this type of marriage. I was just wondering how the Church handles this situation.
Thank you!
Hello Father Joe,
I have a question, What does it mean when I saw a God’s face and his Mother Mary form in the clouds. Thank you.
Hi Fr. Joe,
Is a Josephite marriage valid if the couple does not plan to adopt (that is, they are not “Open to Children” in manners other than marital intercourse)?
Thank you!
Good day Father, I have a question that is a very grey area for me, is downloading pirated software stealing? I always downloaded pirated software from the internet and never even gave it a second thought. It was only until I was looking for a bible software that I actually stopped and thought about whether or not I am stealing. I am not trying to justify stealing I am merely saying that by definition, no one is having anything taken from them nor is anyone at a loss when I download the software? I started looking for answers when I noticed how these Bible software companies charge people thousands of dollars then proceed to write article against piracy with titles like “What happens when you steal a bible”. Is it not the people who are attaining the software by “illegal” means but rather the people who would charge and put a monetary value and seek to collect that value for a service to Gods people who are selfish and self righteous. How can you steal information? Especially Gods Word. Can one raise their hand who really believes God intended us as Christians to sell, barter and profit from the study and enlightenment of his word? It is the greed of men that claim to come in the name of God and his son Jesus Christ. If the makers of these products truly and utterly loved God and followed the teachings Jesus the Christ it would be FREE? I challenge all who would turn away and stand between one of Gods children from bettering themselves and growing closer to him through his word for lack of “the all mighty dollar” to seek Gods face first and see what he has to say… then come back and tell me exactly why men shouldn’t be on your nearest street corner freely handing this product out with open hearts and wide smiles? Jesus never had a cover charge on his sermons, he only took offerings right? In light of what I had just said, I think the better question is “what happens when you sell a bible”. Take this scenario into consideration:
“I left a Bible on the dash of my truck and then thought, what if someone steals it?
It was then that it occurred to me that such an individual, who would take my copy of the Bible, is exactly who needed it most. How can one steal a Bible, whose contents were unquestionably intended to be disseminated freely around the world?
Who is worse, the wretched individual who so desperately seeks to learn more about God that they would do whatever was required, no matter the cost, or the individuals who placed him or her in such a compromise?
The real question is, what happens when you commercialize God? What happens to the person, or group of people, who took the knowledge made freely available to us by God, and then held it hostage and began to extort a king’s ransom?”
Please help me understand if I am in the wrong? Thank you.
Dear Father,
I’ve been very painfully struggling with what might be legalism: I’m so caught up with who is right and who is wrong that I can’t move forward.
To sum it up, in all things, in all relationships, in all situations, I understand it as either I’m being a bad girl, or I’m not being a bad girl; a paralyzing thought. I was raised to believe I’m always wrong and therefore am always a bad girl, but I’m recently being taught that just taking the opposite stance, that the other is wrong and bad, doesn’t help matters either. Just thinking what my father is doing is wrong, my mother was doing wrong, my uncle was doing wrong, etc. just makes me feel angry, bitter, hurt, but also justified for hurting and not wanting anything to do with them. However, if I think the opposite, that I’m wrong, I’m being bad, I feel a very crushing guilt, I feel insane for feeling this hurt, and I suffer from very self-destructive thoughts.
I wish I wasn’t torn in two like this. I don’t think God wants me to be this way.
My counselor advised that I replace my thinking of “who’s right and who’s wrong” with “what’s helpful and what’s unhelpful/harmful”. It sounds a little utilitarian to me, but it does lessen the emotional blow of these things so I can think over them with more clarity and calmness. All the same, I’d like to hear what you’d say as a priest.
Thanks, and I’m sorry if this doesn’t read too clearly. I’m very confused over this.
-Ana
You think I am sick? Well, I am. I am sick of a male chauvinism that taints everything. The ministry of Catholicism is a men’s club where you throw crumbs to women. That is one of the reasons that I turned to the religion of the goddess. If I suffer it is because of what men and the church did to me.
Sometimes it feels like someone else is in my head. Then I look around and find myself in an unfamiliar setting. The worse is when I look into the mirror. I see another person’s face and body. What would you say to this priest?
I made a promise to God and then broke that promise, but then I continued to do what I promised to God I wouldn’t do. Did the promise stop the first time I broke the promise with God? Or does God expect me to continue to keep that promise?
Dear Father Joe:
I am not Catholic. I took my children this evening for their first communion as I want them to be Catholic. For some awful reason I felt the pressure after being called up in front of the church to participate in the communion and did so. I had no idea this was considered such a sin. I had planned on taking classes to become Catholic like my children but now I have read online that I will not be forgiven and this is a “grave” sin. Is this true? I am just beside myself crying and it has ruined such a precious moment for my children. How could I have been so stupid? Please tell me what your thoughts are on this I would greatly appreciate it.
Hello Father, my wife and I have separated and are soon to be divorced. She is divorcing me on grounds of adultery. I admit 9 years ago I did have an affair but went back to my wife. Since then our marriage has dissolved and I have found love with the woman I had the affair with. Both families are of Catholic background. We are both willing to marry and to be baptized as we are unsure if she has been. I know I have not as my mother is Church of England and my father is Catholic [and has been baptized].
Is it possible for us to be married in Catholic Church?
Many thanks for your time. I do pray the answer is yes as I have loved this woman from when we had the affair. I did try to make my current marriage work. We had family support worker and counseling but it didn’t work. My marriage was a civil ceremony at the registry office.
Father, what is our responsibility to prevent others from sinning? I was out at a happy hour with my coworkers and our boss came along. She had two drinks and left almost immediately afterward, and I got the sense when she got up that she was probably not in good shape to drive. She wasn’t obviously drunk, though, and everyone else just said goodbye to her. Because she’s my boss, I felt really uncomfortable and too scared to ask her if she was all right to drive (let alone tell her to give me her keys). How grave a sin was this?
Father,
What is the Church’s teaching when it comes to jokes about religion? For example, if I go see a comedian who makes a joke about Christianity, is it wrong for me to laugh?
Dear Father, why can’t you go to church on a different day than Sunday for our obligation? Recently, all three churches where I attended Mass closed. The only parish open close to me is very crowded, noisy, and distracting. I would rather go every day but Sunday. We are allowed to go Saturday night so why not? Thank You.
Hello Fr Joe, I have a question regarding Israel. Are the Jews the chosen people? I read recently that the Catholic Church is now regarded as the “new Israel.” Could you explain this for me? Thank you Father.