Feel free to submit a new question or concern in the comment box below. Various topics and questions are archived here for easy retrieval. Please be courteous. Comments are moderated so please be patient in waiting for them to appear and for any responses. God bless you!
NEW MESSAGES/HOMILIES CHRISTIAN REFLECTIONS DEFENDING THE FAITH















































Dear Father Joe,
I’m a mother of soon to be 6, this pregnancy has been more than challenging and at times very risky for baby and I. Praise be to God we’re doing okay at the moment but my body is likely not a great candidate for additional pregnancies. My husband has said no more children, he doesn’t want to see me go through this ever again or risk loosing me. He makes sense, my body isn’t handling pregnancy well any longer, and I’m not as young as I used to be. Is it a mortal sin for me a Catholic to have martial relations with my non-Catholic (but amazingly supportive) husband if he chooses to use other methods of avoiding pregnancy during the marital act that are entirely him? After the baby is born, I’m going to work really hard to make NFP work but it will most likely take upwards of two years post baby based on past experience with hormones to get to where I can figure it out to be reliable enough. I’m at a loss on what to do here and could really use your help.
If someone has a terminal illness and is suffering is it OK to hasten death with drugs or otherwise?
I suffer from severe anxiety. Sometimes I masturbate and I can’t seem to control my urges. Is this a mortal sin? Can I receive Communion or do I have to go to Confession every week?
Fr Joe,
I read today that the quadriplegic French man being deprived of water and food by the government died. A pro life internet personality had posted the phone number for the French president and a french script to say when calling it to ask for his life to be spared.
I don’t speak french and was hesitant to call and stumble through this statement. I put it in my mind to ask my husband what he remembered of high school french to see if he could help, but my memory being what it is, I forgot, and never called, and now he is dead and I did nothing, except pray for him.
I feel awful. I don’t know if I sinned by lazy omission or if I just have an over active sense of guilt. What if my call had been the one that was the straw that broke the camel’s back, and I failed? Or am I arrogantly taking too much blame on myself?
Hello Father,
I have a question about something I’ve been doing that I think is unintentional. I am a public school teacher and have been now for 18 years. Back 18 years ago, at age 25, I joined my local union because I thought it was important encase I ever needed legal support and because they work with our school district to get pay raises and other supports for teachers.
Earlier this week, I was reading a blog by Matt Walsh and saw a post about NEA, the National Education Association, coming out and taking a stance to support Roe v. Wade. I am so saddened by this and it does not stand for my pro-life views at all. So I talked with the president of my local union, which I now realize is associated with NEA, and discussed my religious views on this subject as well as how I can go about opting out. Unfortunately the next opt our period isn’t until March, 2020. I guess it’s been written in the by-laws and also mentioned in monthly e-mails but I must admit I am not very good about reading those materials. So this is my failure.
My question is, while I knew there were some left winged individuals that are a part of LEA/NEA, with some beliefs about issues such as homosexuality that do not necessarily align with my view, I never felt my viewpoint wasn’t an option. Maybe I lived in a bubble but I didn’t realize the NEA was necessarily associated with my local teacher union and I also didn’t realize some of my funds could be going to support things like planned parenthood that I do NOT support!
Coming to this realization has taken a mental toll on me and I feel like such a bad person. I know I have taken the steps I need to end my connection with the union this coming March when I can legally opt out but I’m not sure if this is something I need to confess? I have never thought about this union issue in all of the confessions I have made and I tend to be a very scrupulous person. I am just looking for guidance I guess. Is this something I should bring up in confession?
Thanks so much Father!
Mother passed away and will be cremated. Can we have a memorial mass with her ashes in California then later have a burial mass in New Mexico where she will be buried?
Thank you.
Hello Father Joe,
My atheist roommate studies biology and she insists that if God doesn’t have DNA, then Jesus would be a clone of The Holy Virgin and therefore be a woman. How can I explain to her that she is wrong? What is the proof that Jesus was not a clone?
Yours sincerely,
Troubled
Goodafternoon. I had a question. At my work. My boss wich is my foreman has his son. Working with us there but we are all tired of them working my boss isn’t fair he always makes us work hard and his son never does a thing. I was thinking of getting a hold of corporate to let them know wats goin on but then I don’t know if it’s ok with god for me to do this so they can talk to them. Or should we keep taking the unfairness
FATHER JOE:
Hello Father,
Is the native American ritual of smudging (referred to as “Four Directions sacred plant smudging”) approved as allowable in a Catholic Liturgy? It seems that at its root, it’s nothing more than superstition. Yet it is practiced at the Shrine of the North American Martyrs in Auriesville, NY.
Good they’re doing it before the priests in question are retired or dead!
https://www.yahoo.com/news/prominent-detroit-priest-removed-pulpit-190339889.html
https://www.yahoo.com/news/france-vatican-lifts-accused-archbishops-165600293.html
Dear Father,
I would like your opinion on a certain situation. I come from a very catholic background and while I have many questions about Catholicism and it’s doctrine, I still believe there is a God. I am a ballet dancer and I move a lot, depending on where I get a contract to dance. A friend and I are looking for an affordable place to live, as being a dancer it is difficult sometimes to make ends meet. Another, older dancer owns a house close to the place where we rehearse and rents out rooms to other dancers. Both male and female dancers are welcome. Currently there is one male dancer living there. There is a separate bathroom for the girls and guys and everyone has their own room. I know the other dancer that lives there, and he is a responsible, hard worker and we all work long hours and will barely spend much time at home. There is no romantic feelings whatsoever between him or my friend and I.
Living in this house would be the most affordable, doable option.
No part of me feels there is anything wrong with this situation, and I am not asking because of any sort of internal hesitation. This inquiry is solely to know your opinion.
Thank you
Hello Mister Priest, I have a question of a rather theoretical nature. If God were to speak in our language, the words of unworthy humans, could he say the “F” word? Salutations!
Hello, I have a question regarding Catholic travelers. When Catholics travel, do they usually prefer to stay near churches or other specific places?
Hello Fr.
Thank you for taking the time to respond to my questions. Just to respond to your question on the 4th commandment and matrimony question.
Would it be okay if I email my response to you please.
Do you think you’re doing God some kind of service by telling her not to hug in front of you?
Fr. Joe,
Is it a mortal sin to work on Sunday? I’ve looked on the internet and it said nothing about working but it said not going to church is it a sin. I can’t find anything is working on Sunday a sin?
Hi, is homosexual desire a sin? Is homosexual desire and homosexual acts the same thing or are they two different things?
Hi Father,
I work with college students at my college (I am a college student myself) and there are also a few high schoolers, and kids who just graduated high school who work with us. The other college kids promote partying and drinking to the younger kids. Am I guilty of this sin as well since I am around when they promote partying, even if I don’t say anything? Am I committing a mortal sin by not speaking up? The other kids also always add an extra hour on their timesheet so they get more money even if they didn’t work for that hour. They tell the younger kids to do that too. I don’t say anything, but I make sure that I put my correct hours on my timesheet so I don’t get overpaid. Am I sinning by not saying anything?
Another question, can a transgender woman and a transgender man be married in a Catholic church?
Another question Fr.
My brother is a seminarian, order of the Congregation of the Mission, he took his final vows a few months back. I normally send him money, to help him buy things for his study. Is it ok to continue sending him money after he is ordained a priest?
Hello Fr. Joe,
I have a few questions:
1. I read lately, that Pope Francis changed the Lord’s Prayer. Is this true? Can the Pope do that?
2. As a Catholic parent, is it okay to allow either of my sons, (who are baptized Catholics) to take part in a non-Catholic ritual. Like be page boys at their aunt’s wedding, who is a Pentecostal. Background: my husband is a Pentecostal, and he may allow my son to take part but I wouldn’t.
3. How do we determine, the borderline between Mortal and Venial sin?
4. Which is greater, the fourth commandment or the sacrament of matrimony? Background: l feel my husband, would do everything his grandfather says, and not so much me. My man was raised by his grandparents, so he has always known them as his parents. I don’t mind him helping his grandfather, but I don’t like it that he would put him first and me and my children second.
Fr Joe, I could use some advice. I have been trying to decide whether to switch parishes. My current parish is the one I got married in and baptized my children in. I contributed to the building fund (I was upset when they didn’t put kneelers in). I donate financially and also contribute in other ways. But my daughter (she is 22 now). Refuses to go to mass there because someone she knows there insulted her and said his whole family was discussing why she had gotten “so huge”. My efforts to get her to ignore him, or to place God in higher prominence than her ego were unsuccessful. She has said she would go to this neighboring parish, but never did. Then I decided to go to mass there once and she came with me. I reminded her that she had to go to confession before she could receive communion (which she had previously said she’d rather die than do), and she abstained. The following week we were getting ready to go and my husband asked if we needed to leave early for confession and she said she had gone mid week (they do offer that). She received communion. I’m shocked and thinking that maybe I can keep my daughter going to mass if I go with her to this new parish.
Add to that my own concerns:
My current parish priest has taken a good amount of time counseling me. He has been patient and kind and a big help when I was feeling lost. He is rather liberal, though, as I discover from reading your responses to questions on this blog. I am not sure if that is a real issue or not. He is a priest, and therefore more knowledgeable than I. Is that a reason to seek another parish? How do I know what the priests at the new parish think? Surely I am not to interview parish priests like potential hirees?
I also care about this man and don’t want to hurt him. He may understand about my daughter, but he may not. And although I love the church building itself much more than mine, I don’t know the community at the new place. (Not that I wouldn’t in time)
I have prayed for discernment, but haven’t an answer yet, so I thought I would ask for your opinion.
A little girl came missing. Her name is Madeleine McCann. I assume every child has guardian angel.
Why cant her guardian angel reveal where she is at, whether alive or dead. Please!
Hi,
I’m a Observant Jewish in college taking a New Testament course and I just had a question. We Jews believe in the Noahide laws and if non-Jews follow these seven laws (no murder, no idolatry,no blasphemy,no sexual immorality, no stealing, no eating an animal while it is still alive, and establishing fair courts) then they have an equal share in the world to come as any Jew.
My question is how does Christianity think about the Noahide laws? There are times I think it is implied in the second chapter of Galatians by Paul and in Acts 15. I too
Hello Father,
My daughter is bisexual, 23 yrs old and dating a woman. She was bringing her to my house to stay for weekend to attend a friends wedding…she lives 5 hours away. She knows I believe the homosexual act is a sin. They would sleep in separate bedrooms but I also informed her that I didn’t want them to kiss or hug etc. in my home or in front of me. She has pretty much disowned me. Father, was I asking too much? That behavior truly would make me uncomfortable. I would appreciate your input.
Thank you so much.