Feel free to submit a new question or concern in the comment box below. Various topics and questions are archived here for easy retrieval. Please be courteous. Comments are moderated so please be patient in waiting for them to appear and for any responses. God bless you!
NEW MESSAGES/HOMILIES CHRISTIAN REFLECTIONS DEFENDING THE FAITH















































Hello Father Joe
Is crossdressing a mortal sin? I’m a teenage girl and I’m really good friends with this guy i met on an online game. I have zero romantic feelings for him, we are like siblings constantly teasing and laughing at each other. He also has a girlfriend whom I know he loves very, very much. When we skyped each other I had to crossdress because he thought I was a guy, and i just went with it because if his gf finds out he’s toast. I know it’s bad to deceive, especially if you deceive a person who is precious to you, but I just need to know if it’s a mortal sin. I will tell him soon because I can’t bear this secret any longer.
Hoping for swift counsel,
Bea
So it’s my first night in a new house and my friend had stayed the night, we had been moving all day and we’re tired so we fell asleep at 11:00, around 1:30 in the morning I heard something that caused to me wake up, it was a shuffling sound but I couldn’t tell what it was and it was dark as all hell in the room, but then my eyes adjusted and I saw my friend Steven spazzing out on the floor kicking the wall and everything, he then started screaming for his life “stop hitting me, please stop” about 3 times in a row. He sounded like he was in fear of losing his life and my first thought was that somebody had broken into the house and was well, killing him. So scared out of my mind I jumped out of bed and turned the light on but no one was there, upon turning the light on my friend bolted up right and asked what was going on, he had no memory of what was going on and then he fell right back asleep, I tried to go back to sleep as well but I just couldn’t, something didn’t feel right. I decided to just get up and do some research on night terrors and I found multiple accounts of people saying that they believe they are caused by evil spirits. I didn’t wanna go back to bed cause to be honest I was scared and I also wanted to stay up with my friend to make sure that he was alright, he ended up waking up at about 4:00 am and I told him what happened and about what I read online, he said that he’s been having night terrors for years now and that he hasn’t had one in a long time, he also told me that whenever he used to sleep with his rosary on a him that he wouldn’t have them( by the way he did not have his rosary on him that night)… It just seems weird that he hasn’t had a night terror in a long time and when he finally does again it’s in my new house, it’s also weird that he doesn’t have them when signs of Christ/the lord is with him, what do you guys think about this? Should I have a priest bless him or even my house?
Father Joe: I wish you a blessed Sunday. A few of us were discussing the commandments and I raised the question about taking the Lord God’s name in vain. We tried to dissect what Moses was told on Mount Sinai: is it Using his real name to invoke harm/damning on someone or some thing or is it the name man has given him as God. I hope I’ve explained my curiosity enough that you have the gist of my question.
Hello Father,
Back in 1993, my Parish priest call me and said I was no longer welcome to attend Mass because the Church had discovered that I had my tubes tied after having my last baby. I was informed that the worse sin I committed was divorcing my abusive husband.
I was beyond hurt. All of my friends looked down on me. I thought I was doing what was best for my kids. I couldn’t afford to have any more children because my husband refused to support them or me. Thus I got a divorce and was punished for it by the Catholic Church.
I have not attended a Mass in over 26 years.
This past year I battled Breast Cancer. The Church was not there for me. There were no prayers for me. The Church really made me an abandoned and unwanted person.
Then I heard that the Pope was forgiving women who had abortions. I would never have had one of those. Having my last child almost cost me my life. I did not want to bring more kids into the world for which I could not afford to give care. Someone told me to work a second job. Well, I was a Law Enforcement Officer and I was not allowed to take on another job.
Could I be forgiven for getting a Divorce and not having more kids? Or am I forever forbidden to step foot in the local Catholic church? I am really not sure how I would feel if I was welcomed back.
Our family has been invited to a Bar Mitzvah this weekend and this will be our first time attending a synagogue service. The invite was from good friends of ours so we want to attend.
The invitation stated that at the end of the service, there will be a prayer over wine and bread followed by a brief Kiddush (reception with bread and cookies) in the temple Social Hall. Being practicing Catholics, we do not know if it is allowable for us to partake in eating this bread. I have heard that it is wrong for Catholics to partake in communion services at churches of other denominations. I am not sure if that would apply to a case like this, in a Jewish synagogue. Although I am not very knowledgeable in this, I feel that since Christianity is an extension of Judaism, I don’t think there would be anything wrong with eating this blessed bread and it certainly will not change me from being a Catholic. Hope someone can help answer the question.
Henry
Father Joe: Is it ok for a woman to wear a see-through knee length skirt if she wears something under it?
Thank you Father Joe. For your words, and most especially for the listing of fulfilled prophecy. I will take your advice and concentrate on the Scripture, and not on my doubts. Please pray for me.
God bless
I’m a little concerned with my ex wife, she had recently moved back in with me but does not want to get back together and has gone through changes, I get upset with her cause to me , she sounds bonkers, I also get upset cause she wants all the things that make up a happy home and for me to be everything a husband should be, except for the actual husband part, she has been alot less than a respectable person in many eyes, not just mine, and in the last month or so has told she hears and sees things that are not there, like just today I got upset with her for quitting her job and basically wanting to live with me rent free, when I got upset and said that your just a roommate and you need to pay and do your part, she replied with ” I rebuke you in the name of christ”, and that she was saying that to whatever it is that’s attached to me, long story, please help
Hi, I am a Protestant married to a Catholic and I am genuinely trying to understand the reality of transubstantiation. I love most aspects of the Catholic faith but I honestly cannot understand the belief that the elements literally change into the blood and body of Christ. I have spoken to many persons and tried to research the topic, but mainly it seems the answer is that it is a “great mystery” as to how this happens yet plainly one can see that it has not changed. I can accept the principle of the “presence of Christ” being within the elements, but I it seems one must accept the “literal” change. Am I understanding this correctly? What is the explanation of why it is argued a literal change yet it literally looks the same. I mean no disrespect, I honestly cannot wrap my mind around it. Thank you.
Hello Fr.
My post might be long and I’m sorry if I seem to be asking a lot of questions but something happened yesterday. My dad had a talk with me about my going to morning mass everyday because he was worried about my safety. Yes we do have people engaged in the kidnapping business in my country but its not as bad as my dad painted it. He then told me to stop going to morning mass completely, that if I want to go, I should go with him for the 6am mass he normally attends. I don’t like going for 6am masses that’s why I go for 7am masses, and besides I love going alone. I told a priest about it and he said I should obey my dad in imitation of Christ’s obedience to his Father.
Maybe I’m too stubborn or something but my parents think I’m going to mass just to get a distraction because I’m currently waiting for law school. I ve explained to my mother time and time again that she should trust me to know that I can make good decisions for myself concerning my spiritual life. She thinks I’m engrossed in the faith. My question is aren’t I old enough to make my decisions? Why should my dad ban me from going to morning masses? I felt treated like a child. They are so protective of us that I feel controlled sometimes. Does it mean I’m disobedient? Was it God’s will that I should stop going to morning masses for my safety? I ve been going to morning mass for like 7 months now and nothing bad has happened. I ve been extremely upset about it and feel so controlled. I’m now wondering maybe I have a hidden attachment to getting my own way that I haven’t noticed. I’m scared that if I disobey the priest maybe I’m disobeying God.
I hope you don’t get angry at these many questions I ask
you. I value your advice a lot. Thanks.
Father,
How do I make my best friend understand that when an annulment is approved, it is not an act against God or trying to be above God.
She stayed the church is trying to be above God when we issue annulments and they are not in bible. She said it’s better to ask forgiveness and truly repent instead of an annulment. My grandmother received an annulment and remarried and was in peace but my friend said its not real. How do we answer evangelical Christians about this?
Glad you saw Pope Francis!
Thank you for clarification about being able to be married after an annulment is granted. However, my priests stated that my “civil husband” and I should use this time, while waiting for annulment, to be good parents and learn to love each other with our ears, by listening and talking. Due to financial reasons we need to live as siblings.
My question is this: my priest said we can hold hands, hug and kiss but no sexual relations at all. Which we haven’t. He only stated this because of his experience, my annulment looks promising. Is it okay if we do these things? I am also mentally preparing myself if there’s that slight chance it doesn’t go through.
Is it considered murder according to God to put a dog down? Part of me feels like I would be throwing away a gift from God if I put her down. The other part is sad to see her health and condition decrease.
Father Joe, I and several friends prayed for you. Did you get to see Pope Francis?
Please help. Since I was born I’ve had a tumultuous life. Nothing but bad things have happened. Now I am going through a lot my cousin said she was avoiding me because I was possessed by demons, she’s had reoccurring nightmares. She isn’t the first. When I was a run away at 13 a lady I didn’t know took me in and said she dreamt if me being chased by demons. Then ten years later a co worker told me of the same dream. Am I cursed? I’ve had nothing but heartache and tough times. I’m now 42. Please help.
Dear Father Joe: I’m a Bible believing “protestant” (for want of a better word). My question: Has the Roman Catholic Church ever rescinded the anathama by the Council of Trent on Christians like me who believe that salvation is by “grace through faith” in Jesus Christ alone. If not, why not? Surely for the sake of peace, this should be done. Some of my Catholic friends tell me the anathama was nullifed at Vatican II. However, I find no evidence that this is so Perhaps, since Pope Francis is visiting our country, it would be a good time to present this problem to him; and believe me it is a real problem for evangelical believers.
I don’t understand. How are they not the same thing?
Hey Father! So here is my question. I am Catholic, and my wife isn’t. We are having our second child in November. I want to stay faithful to my faith, so I said I don’t want to practice contraception. She said she won’t practice NFP, and is sure that she wants to get her tubes tied. I can’t/won’t condone it, but she said she is going to do it. Besides pray for her/us, what can I do? Am I sinning?
Dear Sir,
I feel very stuck. My counselor told me that the only way I’m going to feel better is to forgive the people who abused and/or hurt me. I know what the Church teaches about forgiveness, but I don’t understand it that way at all. I understand forgiveness to mean letting them hurt me forever, let them have their way with me all they like, no consequences. It means I’m worthless. It means what they did is okay, was good, or I must’ve wanted it somehow. My counselor got very angry when I told him this. It scared me, and confused me: why is he angry at the evil that happened, but at the same time tells me to forgive or never heal?
What should I do? If what I understand forgiveness to be is wrong, how can I learn the truth?
Thanks,
-Ana
Hello Father Joe,
I hope this message finds you well.
Father, I am going through an extremely difficult time of severe doubt. I have never before suffered such strong doubt in my faith, and it is worrying me terribly.
I am doing my confirmation next year, and attend weekly classes at my parish. Last week, after a lesson on the different books in the Bible, and comparisons between Jewish scripture and our own, I found myself walking away from the class wondering who decided which books made it into our scripture. I wondered about the gospel of Thomas and other such texts that claim that Jesus was married etc.
I must mention that two weeks ago, I purchased the Diary of St. Faustina. I read a few quotes from the diary, and they gave me such comfort, that I decided to get the whole book. However, from almost the very beginning of the book, I kept having thoughts that she was imagining this. That she couldn’t possibly have seen Jesus, and that her musings are far too intimate, almost as though she were speaking to a lover. I haven’t picked up the book again. Now it pains me to even write down these thoughts that went through my head.
Yesterday, after all the doubts and strange thoughts I’ve been having, I decided to do some research regarding the Jewish scripture and our own. The only thing that I managed to get from this is that Jesus didn’t fulfil the requirements for the Messiah. And this has now made my doubt even worse. I read a whole bunch of Catholic answers to this problem as well, and understand that Jesus will fulfil these with the Second Coming.
However my doubt is now ten times worse. I keep thinking “What if we got it all wrong? What if He wasn’t the messiah?”
I cant tell you how much it pains me to have these thoughts. I feel like a traitor of the worst kind. I feel lost Father. And I don’t know how to get rid of this doubt. I have prayed for God to lead me to the truth. I have read countless opinions on the matter, and none of them bring me any relief (understanding). I know in my heart of hearts that the Jesus who I love is truly the Son of God, but I can’t get rid of this thought that I’m wrong.
Any advice would be very much appreciated.
God bless you
Father Joe, Are you going to have an opportunity to see the Pope?
Hello. I am issued a company car by my employer, & as an employee, I am technically not supposed to use it for anything that is not business-related. However, there have been instances in which I have driven it to a local parish when I needed to go to confession. I have always only done this during a break from work or in the process of going to work, although the parishes are 5-6 miles off of my normal route. Since I was using the company car, which contains company gas, it occurred to me that this could be considered theft. Is this a mortal sin? Thank you, Father
I will be attending a Baptism tomorrow (Sunday) at 2:30. I have to check if it’s a full Mass but if so, would that Mass fulfill the Sunday obligation?
Dear Fr Joe,
I am a single girl almost 40 years of age. I live at home due to health issues and financial constraints related to inability to work.
I value my relationship with God and my Catholic faith and try to grow closer to God and He doesnt fail me. Unfortunately my prayer life and spiritual reading have suffered due to too much time spent on the internet where i find virtual interactions no better than my shaky real life connections with others.
My major problem i believe is loneliness. I feel my life is empty and i feel hopeless and overly anxious to a point of wishing i could just die God forbid by my own hand.
I try challenge myself to try new experiences like i have been advised but the anxiety flares up like on a new learning project i took up recently i may just lose the money i paid for the course when i fail the test due to lack of confidence.
I realise you are not a therapist or psychiatrist but i would as always appreciate your insight and advice.
Thanks and God bless you.
Dear Father Joe,
I’m trying to translate a sentence to Latin, but I’m not completely sure about the result. Could you confirm/correct it for me, please?
“The deadline is our muse.”
“Nostra musa est ultimum minutis.”
With regards,
Attila