Feel free to submit a new question or concern in the comment box below. Various topics and questions are archived here for easy retrieval. Please be courteous. Comments are moderated so please be patient in waiting for them to appear and for any responses. God bless you!
NEW MESSAGES/HOMILIES CHRISTIAN REFLECTIONS DEFENDING THE FAITH















































Hi Father,
My husband and I are both Catholic and since the day we were married, we have always been open to life. We had a daughter after our first anniversary but faced infertility for the next 10 years that was unexplained. We continued to trust God and refused to take fertility medicine to force things to happen as doctors tried to push, and God blessed us 10 years later with a son, conceived naturally. That was 4 1/2 years ago. Since my son was six months old and over the next 4 years, we have suffered the loss of 6 babies at different stages of pregnancy , two at 8 weeks, one at 16 weeks, one at 21 weeks (cord accident), one at 14 weeks and on Monday (12-10) at 11 weeks. Outside of the son at 21 weeks which was from the cord wrapped around his neck, doctor’s do not give me any reasons why I’m a losing these babies but that it is probably my age. They have never said that I should not have anymore children however. My own doctor has said there is nothing wrong with me and that she has many many patients in their forties have children. I am 42. With several of these losses I did end up with some complications that required emergency care in a hospital but it was handled and I was back home the same day. The care by doctors in the hospital when I would have a complication was humiliating and they treat us like we are foolish for being pregnant in the first place. My husband and I want to be open to life at all times and welcome any child that God wants to bring into our lives but at the same time are we getting the message wrong from God. I’m confused about what God wants from us. Why is he allowing this door to stay opened at this stage of our lives if each life continues to end this way. I thought he wanted us to welcome a lot of children but why do we continue to be heartbroken each time. Sometimes I feel I am being greedy because I have two beautiful children so why should I want more. One of the hardest parts of this whole situation is the judgement from family and others. It’s easy for people to look at our situation and simply say, “Oh you have lost multiple children, I think that is a message to not have more”. Is it really that simple? By the loss of our third baby, people were saying, “It’s irresponsible, selfish, you shouldn’t be having anymore, you already have two children, you should be careful,” etc. These are also people that do not understand what being open to life even means. We feel now we have to hide any pregnancy and then suffer in silence just the two of us when we suffer another loss, just like this past Monday. It is an incredibly lonely feeling. Are we being faithful to God by continuing to be open to life at all times no matter how heartbreaking or painful it is, or are we being foolish? We are so confused at this point.
Thank you for any insight you can give to our confused and broken hearts.
Father, your response to a previous questioner was that in heaven we will have our bodies. But our bodies are made of matter. I thought that heaven was a spiritual place. Is heaven a physical place as well? Maybe this is simply a mystery and we won’t know until we get there.
Hello Father,
Thank you for your detailed response! It was very reassuring to me. However, I still have some questions about the afterlife. Is Hell real in the literal sense–meaning, is the torment depicted in the Bible symbolic of being distanced from God? Or does it literally mean that souls must spend eternity suffering?
Again thank you so much for the help and Merry Christmas!
Hello, my brother found some money (around $60) in a parking lot and is keeping it. Is that considered theft? Should I tell him not to?
My husband and I are not religious. He never was and I left the Christian (Protestant) faith after realizing that the very flawed teachings I received led me to have an unhealthy relationship with myself and the world, among other things, to which I will get shortly.
My husband’s sister and mother are active Catholics. They sat during our Protestant service and took the vows to support and nurture our marriage— from which point they have undermined it for thirteen years.
There have told lies about me to my husband behind my back. They consist of constant complaints or fabrications of petty infractions. “She didn’t talk to me when I wanted.” “I don’t like talking to her on the phone.” There have also been passive-aggressive “Mean Girl” stunts.
I believe efforts to undermine our adopting were made with negative reports to the adoption agency. “You’re too old to have kids.” There is even cyber-stalking of a now-defunct blog with complaints about what I wrote (when it wasn’t about them). His sister has more than once called me and just started screaming at me. And yet, she says she doesn’t know why I asked her not to call me anymore.
My husband still tries to have a relationship with them; but others have noticed, along with my friends and family, that the sister is the clear favorite who is indulged and spoiled. On the other hand, my husband, an accomplished, intelligent professional, who is a loyal, sober, faithful husband and a helpful, dedicated son, seems to be tolerated, except when he’s needed to be a free handyman or computer service technician or cat-sitter.
I’m not perfect, but I’m a stable, loyal, faithful wife who has often supported him in helping when they need it. I don’t keep him from functions, but I don’t go. I’m a professional who has earned equal or more than my husband throughout most of our marriage; but they’ve hinted to me that I married him or I’m exploiting him for his money. They count my drinks at functions (1-2 if any) after I got a bit tipsy once four years ago, snub me and even him sometimes, and allow their relations to insult and belittle me at gatherings with no apology.
I digress, but it was in the interest of background. Suffice to say at this point, they are a strain on our marriage, and at some point I nearly left just to get away from them.
Is it a violation of some rule or principle of the Catholic faith to undermine or even try to break up a marriage? Why would “Good Catholics” behave this way? Honestly, seeing self-proclaimed Christians behave this way is one of the few things that drove me from the Christian faith.
Dear Father,
I’ve been an atheist for most of my life, but lately, I’ve been adopting more of my mother’s Catholic values. I still have doubts about the true existence of a higher power, and I long for God to send me a sign. I’m also frightened by the thought of the existence of Hell. Would it really be a place of eternal torment? The idea terrifies me. I feel conflicted and deeply depressed by my desire to return to Christianity and simultaneous fear of believing. Can you offer any suggestions?
Thank you Father.
Father Joe, thank you so very much for your answers to my end of life questions. They are really VERY helpful. It is difficult to watch my mom go downhill physically and mentally and feel so helpless. I bring her Communion each week from Mass and she’s very grateful for that and Hospice now has a priest bringing her Communion as well. My dad died suddenly, so I’ve not experienced this journey with a parent before. I offer up her sufferings, (as well as my own and my rosaries), to repair for her sins and for a holy death for her since she’s mentally not very capable to do that for herself anymore. I pray for her daily. Again, thank you very much! Your blog is a godsend in this very troubled world.
Also, Father, in conjunction with my previous question on end of life issues, can we as Catholics have a DNR? I really don’t know what is ok and not ok with end of life. I’m the only one of my siblings who continues to be a practicing Catholic and before we possibly get to a critical place with my mom, I need to have things clear in my own mind so that I can stand ground with my non practicing siblings, if need be.
Father Joe, I need help navigating end of life issues. My mom is 91, has congestive heart failure, bad dementia, is blind, and is down to 88 lbs. because she won’t eat much or is not hungry. She is mostly non-compliant with any help we try to bring in or to help her feel better. Both her doctor and a visiting nurse that we’ve had coming in to oversee her since her latest hospital stay have suggested it’s time for hospice. We’ve noticed she’s been sleeping a good part of the day now, is trying to divvy up her belongings between us kids and is talking a lot about my dad and my brother, both who are dead. We have spoken to hospice, whose focus is palliative care instead of trying to get her better, of course. We’ve been focused on getting her better for 9 yrs. No one thinks there is any “better” to get her to at this point, both because of her condition and her non-compliance. My question is: what does our Catholic faith say about end of life care? If something medical were to happen, are we obligated to take her to the hospital or can we keep her home and comfortable and let nature take its course without extra measures? I need to be sure we don’t step over the line, but just not sure where that line actually is. Any guidance you can give me will be most appreciated and thank you for this forum and for your faithful service as a priest.
What do you think it means father? I am Irish Catholic. Nonsense is not an open mind for a priest I want to know what this message means for me.
Thank you, no wonder the church is in ruins in good old USA.
is masturbation a sin?
The following religious message appeared on my mobile can you decode please.
Hi 34 11 sorry for the 6667t3diiyttu
FATHER JOE: Seems like nonsense to me.
Fr. Joe:
Dec. 8 is the First Friday of Dec, as you know. If I attend the Vigil Mass that evening, would it satisfy my First Friday devotion? Or should I receive Eucharist at morning mass then attend the Vigil Mass? I am u able to attend mass on Dec. 8.
Hi Father. My husband came out to me as transgender and wants to transition to a woman. Will my marriage become annulled?
I feel alienated and excluded more and more each Sunday. I’ve been going to a 6:30 am mass on Sundays for the reason I can say the prayers, participate and feel good about the service. Since a new pastor has taken over he has initiated the singing of prayers at this early mass. He has not only alienated me four fellow parishioners stated they would not becoming back. I know others who feel this way. Another problem is part of this is a plan to do away with this mass time rumor has it. What would be the right way of confronting these issue I have with the pastor, I will be looking to find another church to call home
Thank you
Hi Fr Joe,
With the Holy Day of obligation for the Immaculate Conception on a Saturday, does going to Mass on Saturday evening fulfill the obligation for that Holy Day? Or, is it only Mass in the morning that is valid for the Immaculate Conception? I am working on Saturday morning, but if I went to the 5pm Mass on Saturday and then Mass on Sunday morning, would I be fulfilling both obligations? Or does Saturday night Mass cover me for both the Holy Day and Sunday obligation? Thanks for clarifying.
Lauren
is it a mortal sin to not apologize to someone? I inadvertently offended someone in my class when he asked me a question about a presentation I did. I kind of feel bad, but also I have never spoken to this person before that encounter so we don’t really have a relationship, so I’m not sure if I’m obligated to apologize or anything.
Hello Father,
I have a strong desire to go to Confession but am not sure if it is appropriate or not. I’m currently battling an active drug addiction. I recently reached out for help and will be starting a rehabilitation program in a few days.
Even though I have a plan in place that I pray will give me the assistance I need to overcome this (I can’t do it without help); I am still an active drug user. Do I have to wait until I’ve successfully completed my rehab and am in full recovery before I can go to Confession? Would it be a sin or invalid if I went now? Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
Thank you for your time,
Mark
Dear Father,
I have come across the writings of Saint Leonard of Port Maurice. Are you familiar with him? He states that only 2 or 3 people in one hundred thousand will be saved. Can this possibly be true? Yes, I know his belief sounds very extreme but he is a canonized Saint in the Roman Catholic Church.
Hi Father Joe,
Do you know of any priests who pray deliverance prayers for people over the phone or through skype? I live in a country where the priests dont know much about deliverance and Im not getting the help I need. I tried to get help from them and they were not able to help much. I need someone experienced in dealing with deliverance. Any help would be much appreciated. Thanks
Father,
I’m a teenager and I’m Catholic. My parents aren’t. I’ve committed several mortal sins and I want to go to confession, but my parents won’t take me, and I don’t have a car. I have no way of getting to church, but I can’t live with these sins on my conscience. Please help and thank you.
Thank you. I generally do as you said in the morning….saying it silently or in a very low voice. My wife and I will say it vocally in the evening together. I appreciate your being able to clarify things for us. Thank you!
I know we are to recite the Office and not do it mentally. But is it permissible if you do not recite it vocally as to not disturb others, as in the early morning hours while others in the house are sleeping?
Is masturbation still a sin if you don’t do it while thinking lustful thoughts? Say you just do it because it feels good–like scratching your back or getting a massage. Is it still bad?
Hello Father,
I was considering getting a tattoo of a cross as well as a bible excerpt done on my chest and was wondering what the Catholic Church’s views on tattoos were. Are tattoos sinful? I seek permission before deciding on my first tattoo, if allowed. Thank you for your time.