Feel free to submit a new question or concern in the comment box below. Various topics and questions are archived here for easy retrieval. Please be courteous. Comments are moderated so please be patient in waiting for them to appear and for any responses. God bless you!
NEW MESSAGES/HOMILIES CHRISTIAN REFLECTIONS DEFENDING THE FAITH















































Hi Father Joe,
I was wondering i can can specifically bring in things I’m having trouble forgiving, into confession. I know confession is also a healing sacrament. So, if I’m carrying the hurt and wounds from a few things, can I talk about those specifically and share what those wounds are as far as my feelings about how they have caused me pain? And then can I ask for forgiveness for holding onto resentment and anger (even though I still do) and also ask for the help to find forgiveness in my heart? Thank you Father Joe, Rachel
Hello Father. I know we are supposed to wait on the Lord for things, such as a spouse. I wanted to join catholic match just to see who is out there. Where I am from the men around me are either non church goers or of another religion and I’d really like a Catholic spouse. I am wondering if it is okay for me to fully join the match website or if I should not and just wait to be sent someone also I was wondering how do I know if God sent this person? Thank you peace & many blessings.
How is Jesus a model for Christian living?
Some time ago in a weak moment and wanting to feel well I called a friend who was Wiccan to ask about his charmed life. He told me to buy a book; the practical witch. He said it was how nature heals us. I ordered the book but it never got ordered (divine intervention). I never sought it out again believing this to be Gods will. Did I sin by even considering this, and if I had the blessing of the sick, can I forget this?
Hi Father- For the past couple weeks, when I pray, it seems like I am feeling nothing. It feels like God isn’t there like He was before. I’ve had this happen for a day or two, but it’s never gone on this long. I keep praying, but nothing. It makes me want to pray less and I can’t help but wonder if it’s something I did, or has God left me? Any thoughts on this, and is there something I can do to make this better?
Evan
That’s helpful answer, Fr. Joe. Thank you.
Is purgatory something to be afraid of? Do we believe that it’s painful to be there?!
I feel, given my sin, I will likely end up in purgatory, or suffering really painful death, or some kind of harsh suffering to atone for that sin. I deserve it, but at the same time I fear and dread it as well. There is not a day that goes by that I don’t have regret….and struggle with self-forgiveness. I wish I could take it back, but that is not possible. Am I right to have a concern with possibly facing temporal punishment either in this life or the next? Thank you.
Hi Father Joe,
Could you explain temporal punishment? When we receive forgiveness for sins with true remorse and carry out the penance, are those sins then freed of temporal punishment too?
Say we have committed a grave sin in our past, were truly remorseful, confessed that sin, received God’s forgiveness, carried out our penance, and vowed to never commit that sin again. Do we still owe God some debt for that sin? If so, why? And, can the struggles of our lives be what fulfills that temporal punishment? Or, are there ways we can actively make amends here on earth so as not to have to have to do this in purgatory. How do you know if you have sufficiently atoned for your sins?
Thank you,
Lauren
Hello Fr. Joe,
I work for a company as a graphic artist (salaried). Work has its ups and downs. Sometimes it’s busy and other times I’m waiting for new work to come in. During the down times I usually let my boss know that I’m available to help if needed. More often than not I’m told there isn’t anything to help with at the moment. Even though I’m salaried, I still have to charge my time to a Job Number. My dilemma – there is no work for me to do, yet I’m at the office.
When I hear that nothing is required of me, I go back to my desk and surf the web, read online or do personal work.
What should I do? Is the above allowable, is it sinful, or is it preferred that I make up work for myself to do such as clean up files, think of graphics to make, learn a new skill set, etc… Am I being too scrupulous or am I correct in questioning my actions?
The same question goes for if I’m working from home, logged into the company network, and no new work comes in.
Thank you Fr. Joe.
Hello Father, I hope this finds you well. My question is a bit of a mature one. It has to do with how Catholics should view sexual desire and pleasure. I was recently told, to make a long story short, that sexual desire is the root cause of sexual sin, and therefore it and any pleasure gained from sex should be viewed with utter disdain as something unfit for rational beings. All my knowledge of Catholic teaching says this is an un-Catholic attitude. What are your thoughts?
Hi Father, My question is about forgiveness. I’ve had some rough things happen growing up. These things have impacted my life greatly. I really don’t want to forgive, especially when there is no remorse, no apology, and no regret by those who have hurt me. Is it a sin not to forgive under these circumstances, and how would forgiving them help me? Any suggestions on how to forgive when it’s really hard!?! Thank you, Nate
Hi Father,
I was reading a few queries on confessions and I thought to share some things my family were discussing yesterday … we were watching my uncles silver jubilee celebration as a priest and my brother brought up a story about my aunt who was lining up for confession and as she entered the confessional booth; she saw her brother inside; same time she did an about turn and went to the other booth (where a different priest was in). We all kinda laughed at my aunt’s behavior but then Fr. we started thinking how we would behave; when our brother is ordained a priest; will we be just the same as our aunt. My sister said that we shouldn’t look at our brother as our sibling but as a representative of Christ when he is the confessional booth. I guess we’re just being human; but when it comes down to the necessity of the sacrament; we’d probably put our human thinking behind us. But Fr. have you ever had any experience like so with your family.
The primaries are coming up for my state for like governor and other offices. Is it a sin not to vote in them? I really don’t know much about any of the candidates, and it is hard to find out a lot in only a few days.
I go to Mass every Saturday. 8:30 AM. Very few people there, maybe 15, but one woman who is always there, does not bow when she comes in, remains seated during the opening and as best I can tell does not follow along during Mass. At all. Yet she receives communion and takes a host with her. As if she is s Eucharistic minister. She also leaves early. She is not elderly or handicapped.
In a room filled with very few people this sticks out to me. As deliberate disrespect. Why would the Priest not notice, or he does yet he tolerates this disrespectful behavior? It’s that obvious. This isn’t once in awhile but EVERY SATURDAY MORNING MASS. She doesn’t even say PEACE to anyone. She doesn’t move. Head down.
Is it a sin to donate to a thrift shop that some people have said supports Planned Parenthood?
Hello- my dad told me that his coworker had an affair and was fired and I was kind of mad that he told me because I feel like it was detraction. And I just went to confession, but now my brother care over and my dad was about to spread the gossip to my brother and I didn’t stop my dad from gossiping and he told my brother. Did I commit a mortal sin by not preventing detraction?
Thank you Fr. Joe!!
I feel a little better about my worry about our priest remembering my confession. I didn’t think how it’s probably hard on him too sometimes! Not so much because of the sins he hears, but because he wants to do a good job for us, and I’m sure it can be difficult at times. I really like our priest, he has a good heart. And because it’s a small town and a small church, it’s like a family with him in the middle of it all. That’s why it feels awkward a little, because we know him so well. But he definitely cares about all of us and says he wants to help us all get to Heaven, so I will try to remember that too. And you’re right, I think it’s hard to hear yourself say the things you’ve done and admit it to yourself!!
Someone I know (from another state) said that he questioned the priest about giving a really small penance even after he confessed a lot of things. The priest said that he gave a small penance to him because the priest himself planned to pray and do some penances on his behalf. Is this something that happens often or is it rare? Do priest take of penances for the people who they hear confessions?! Can you ask to have the full penance to do yourself if the penance seem light?
Just curious.
God Bless,
Rachel
Hi Fr Joe,
I read most of the questions and answers that get posted here. You give straightforward answers in an honest and helpful way. Please, can you tell me, do priests really not remember confessions? When you hear a confession, how do you not remember what is said? Or do you remember? How do you not think of a persons sins when you see them outside of Confession afterwards?
I live in a very small town, with a small Catholic Church, one priest, and a long distance to the next church. I need to go to confession, but haven’t been in a long time. I have some tough things to confess, and I’m nervous. But also, it’s pointless to go behind the screen. He will 100% know who I am anyways. We are lucky to have such a good priest who is kind and compassionate. What holds me back is that I’m worried about feeling awkward after thinking he will remember what I confessed when he sees me,
Do priests really forget confessions?!
Thanks Fr Joe!!
Rachel
How can my fiance be baptized? He did RCIA from November 2017 to March 2018 but his employer would not allow his Easter Vigil baptism. Now our priest says he has to wait until next Easter. How can my fiance be baptized now? He understands the Sacraments, the Mass and of course Transubstantiation. He really wants the Lord in Communion and is devoted to Mother with the Rosary.
Please help!
Robin and Tony
How can my fiance get baptized when his job would not allow him to be baptized at Easter Vigil and now our priest says he has to wait until next Easter? Why can’t adults be baptized throughout the year?
Hi Father. Thank you for answering my previous queries. I just have some questions regarding confession.
Let’s say a penitent is having doubts if he had comitted the sin of heresy, with all conditions present in Canon law for the heretic to be excommunicated, confesses that he is unsure if he’s excommunicated to the priest, and the priest wrongly judges that he’s not excommunicated, and gives the penitent absolution.
Is the confession valid even if the penitent is indeed excommunicated although he was genuinely confused that he is? Is the excommunication lifted even if the priest who gave absolution has no authority from the Bishop to lift the excommunication? Thank you!
Hi Father Joe,
I just need some reassurance and words of comfort.
Today my cousin called me to meet her at the hospital. Her dad (My Uncle Harry) was deteriorating fast. She was by herself in the hospital room (since her husband was in Florida on business and her brother lives 3 hours away), and she wanted someone to be there with her for the end. About 1/2 hour after I arrived at the hospital (as I was holding one hand and my cousin was holding the other) my Uncle Harry took his last breath and passed away. It was 2:45pm this afternoon.
This was a first for me, to be present as a family member died. I saw him take his last breath, and I felt his pulse slowly weaken and stop.
It was peaceful and unsettling at the same time. Sadness and relief (he had been in so much pain). It was an end and a new beginning. I feel a little numb. I didn’t anticipate that I would experience this today, but feel as though it was a privilege too. My Uncle Harry was a great guy, he loved watching baseball and playing golf, was a Civil War expert and a wonderful dad/grandfather. He loved the beach and throwing Kentucky Derby parties. He missed his wife (my aunt) who died over 20 years ago. And, he loved God immensely and practiced his Catholic faith with enthusiasm,devotion, and joy. The fullness of human experiences sometimes include moments that stretch us from one extreme to another simultaneously. I think this was one of those moment for me.
I feel a bit shaken. Unsettled. But at the same time, thankful for his example of a life well lived, and the privilege for being able to hold his hand at the end. He lived 86 full years.
Please, if you had any thoughts or words of reassurance to share about this experience, I would appreciate it. I feel restless and doubt I’ll be able to sleep tonight…which is ok. I think I’m a little overwhelmed and having some difficulty processing all that happened.
God Bless you Father Joe.
Peace,
Sarah
God Bless you Wayne and Fr. Joe (and all priests).
Praying the the weight of any burdens be lightened.
May God’s love and peace surround us all.
Trust in God’s Mercy
Father:
As a man now in his 70’s I often think of my sinfulness throughout my life with shame, humility, anxiety and sorrow. I try hard to lead a life now that will bring me closer to God. But over and over, I disappoint my self and God. I know very well that I cannot change what I did in my sinfulness in those many years that have past.
Beyond that, knowing that I am in the “sunset years” of my life, the thought of my coming judgment is a burden, as it should be I suppose. Sometimes, as I think about my life, visions, snapshots and recollections of those sins and their circumstances blaze across my mind. I struggle to put them out of my mind so that I will not revisit them. But they are always there and all to easily surface at the most inappropriate times. Always there.
In confession, I was told once told the priest about that and he responded by saying that my sinfulness is my “baggage”; something that all of us will “haul” along with us through life.
Another issue for me is that while I know that I did confess my sinfulness in the past, I must say that I know that I did not feel the true weight of those sins like I do now. This leaves me with a sense of despair. I know that we say after confessing that we are sorry for “these sins and all the sins of my past life”. I always think this is my opportunity to revisit that sinfulness and restate my sorrow for past actions.
I know that God loves me as I am. I also know that my sinfulness has hurt him. I also know that I cannot go back and change my life. But, I can try to live a better and more spiritual life. As I attend Mass I always think that all of these people around me, while sinful, have probably lead much more holy lives than me. It leaves me with remorse and anxiety knowing that God will look at me and make his judgment as to what eternity will be for me.
I guess this “baggage” will always be with me.
Hi Father! Have you seen the movies Despicable Me 3 or Captain Underpants? Do you think children should not watch them? Because they were shown(every Friday is movie day) at the childcare place I work at and I’m not sure if I should speak up and recommend that those not be shown again because there are some parts that may not be the best for children or that we should pay more attention to the movies we show. But they were technically children’s animated movies. If I don’t speak up, is that a sin? Should I speak to the employee who brings in the movies every Friday or my boss? I’m about to go away for the summer so I don’t have much time to talk to anyone.