Feel free to submit a new question or concern in the comment box below. Various topics and questions are archived here for easy retrieval. Please be courteous. Comments are moderated so please be patient in waiting for them to appear and for any responses. God bless you!
NEW MESSAGES/HOMILIES CHRISTIAN REFLECTIONS DEFENDING THE FAITH















































Since it’s Lent, is it ok to have a birthday celebration with cake and treats?
Dear Fr. Joe,
Please suggest to me a sacrifice I can do to offer so that my wife will have the grace and correspond to that grace (of submissiveness, docility, dutifulness and respect). She is supposed to be a traditional Catholic but it seems that spiritual pride has gotten the better of her and she would act as if she knows better than me, her husband, most of the time. She would insist on doing what she wants despite my contrary decision. If I would point this out to her, she would only get more angry and try to get the children to be against me. That is why I try to be quiet.
I realize only prayer and sacrifice can rectify this. I am hurting inside. That is why I am asking for your suggestion on what sacrifice I can do so that she will change for the better.
Thank you very much in advance.
I totally agree, David. A lot should be brought back and a lot needs to go. For example, the hand-holding during the Our Father needs to be totally banned. Also, (and more importantly), the tabernacle should be on the altar and in the center. In some churches, you can’t even find it. So much needs to be fixed.
Just interesting.
Judy S. Tilly
Sent from my iPhone
>
P.S. please add this to my reply. For me it’s not a simple case of English vs. Latin or traditional vs modern. For me the main thing is I wish I could experience a Mass where the congregation was at least as respectful as what I experienced c. 1980. It seems to me that many things have changed since then, both in the Mass and in the attitude of people.
For example, what happened to incense, ringing of bells, etc. What happened to asking people to remain in their seats at the end of Mass instead of rushing out during the final hymn? What about some kind of basic dress code? We are going to Mass, not to a movie or to the shopping mall.
I attended guitar masses in the early 1980s that were very beautiful and there was a great mood of reverence. So I’m not asking for a Gregorian chant service all the time, although that would be wonderful sometimes.
Perhaps some of us think if we revert to older forms, some of the old atmosphere of reverence would return? I’m not sure if it would.
I would just add one more thing. When I go to Mass, I would like to see a prominent statue of the Blessed Virgin Mary, instead of having a small statue in the back where it is hard see. I believe that Mary is the way to Jesus, just as Jesus is the way to the Father. When I pray to Mary to banish sinful thoughts from my mind, they go away!
Thank you.
Dear Fr. Joe,
I trust your judgment. Since you have posted my question, I would like to make a follow-up statement. I would just like to add that I have decided to pay no attention to these SSPX churches and to stay within my parish church. There is only one true Church, and in my heart I know it is our Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church, led by the Pope. I think I should stay at my parish and pray for our priests and our bishop, and resist any temptation to schism.
I can go to the parish in my city that does offer the Tridentine Latin Mass on occasion if I want to. Even though it is across town, it is hardly a great sacrifice to go there if I really want to. But ordinarily I will attend Mass at my own parish, even if I am uncomfortable with some things that go on.
For example, I can never get used to seeing grown men walk into the Mass wearing shorts instead of long pants. This is so disrespectful. I believe this would never have been allowed prior to Vatican II.
I can only speak for myself, based on my own conscience, but I believe it is my duty as a Roman Catholic to resist any temptation to join a schismatic group. The Holy Father is Peter.
Thank You,
David
[While you had some misgivings about these questions, what you bring up is important. I have taken the liberty of editing your questions and making a response. I hope this is okay.]
Dear Fr. Joe,
I would strongly prefer to attend the traditional Mass, even though the Holy Father has criticized those of us who have that preference. Frankly, I think his criticism is unjustified.
Here is what the Holy Father says:
“I always try to understand what’s behind people who are too young to have experienced the pre-conciliar liturgy and yet still they want it. Sometimes I found myself confronted with a very strict person, with an attitude of rigidity. And I ask myself: Why so much rigidity? Dig, dig, this rigidity always hides something, insecurity or even something else. Rigidity is defensive. True love is not rigid.”
There is one official parish church in my rather large city that currently offers the traditional Mass on Sunday, but it is difficult for me to reach due to transportation issues. On the other hand, there is a SSPX church almost within walking distance. But on the diocese website it says that SSPX church is schismatic, and attending Mass there does not fulfill the Sunday obligation.
In fact I wish to support my local parish, but I also wish to support the authorized church that still maintains the traditional Mass. So I’m considering attending the traditional Mass on Sundays, in spite of transportation difficulties, and then attending my parish church on a weekday.
But I would also like the option to attend Mass at the SSPX church. So any clarification on this issue would be appreciated. Thank you.
Thank you Fr. Joe for your response to my question on salvation on February 27, 2018 at 10:12 pm.
Thank you Helen and Father Joe.
Hi Father,
My question was on the same line as Helenl and you have answered it.
thank you so much.
Concerning the question from Talei about Lent. I, too, find this confusing. Are Sundays during Lent fast days (because they are in Lent), feast days (because we celebrate the Christ’s Resurrection), or both in that joyful Catholic both/and way? Do we abstain form the things we have “given up” on Sundays? I understand moderation. And I understand Lent is not just about giving up physical things but about growing closer to the Lord in so doing, giving to the poor, thinking or others more than self, etc.. I also know Lent isn’t about “doing it right,” but Church teaching on Sundays in Lent is confusing at best and mostly nonexistent.
Your story so represents the hateful unkind abuse from members in my own family. Not sure if the father sees my reply here but here goes.Coming from a background of long and deep standing abuse in my older age of 69 I find myself unable to ‘weather’ the mean spiritedness that vents towards me. Charity and prayer is always ongoing but I am unable to sustain the blows. What would Father Joe advice be where I am unable to reach out with charity kindness and sustain an ongoing relationship as the continued harassment antagonism continues. Thank you.
Hi Father,
Not sure if i’m asking this question correctly; but i’ll give it a try. Is Sunday included in Lent?
shalom.Actually,the one who said “No, if they leave the Church and convert to another religion they are no longer Catholic, but they are still validly baptized” is the priest.i wonder why some of the priest contradict catholic teaching.
Hello Father, Thank you for your blog. I work with the homeless and would like to be able to offer them a blessing. Could you please tell me a good general blessing that would help lift the homeless out of their despair? Thank you, Ian C.
I realize that I must go to confession if I have committed a mortal (vs. venial) sin. I believe that I am a good person. I do my very best to avoid temptation and follow God’s will. However, the reality is that I fall into sinful thoughts and actions because I am weak, even though I pray fervently for God’s help. With all this being said, I must admit that I likely commit mortal sins a few times each week. So how often must I go to confession? I would like to participate in Communion as often as I can. However, most priests are unavailable every day. Usually just once a week.
shalom.thanks for the answer.I’ve asked that question to the other priest n cathechist n they said “Yes,they are still catholic even though the convert to another religion” but some of them said “No, if they leave the Church and convert to another religion they are no longer Catholic, but they are still validly baptized”.Honestly I’m a little bit confuse which one is the correct answer.
Good morning and thank you for your response Fr. Joe.
Dear Fr. Joe,
I have a question about delectatio morosa. If one has had impure thoughts, must he tell the priest in confession which sins he committed in his imagination (example: sodomy rather than simple fornication etc.)? I have made a bit of research about it on Google Books, and it seems to me that old moral theology texts hold sometimes contrasting opinions. Some even hold that delectatio morosa of a given sin is a sin of the same species as the sin imagined (although I find it difficult to believe that, for example, having fun thinking about killing someone can be considered substantially the same as homicide itself), others seems to hold more moderate opinions, and several books say something about theologians who believe it’s not necessary to tell the priest about the circumstances of the imagined sin.
I’m quite confused, and I would like to have precise knowledge of how specific one has to be in confession about sins of delectatio morosa.
Shalom.I have a question.Once people are baptized Catholic, are they Catholic forever?If someone leave catholic faith for another religion or convert to another religion (etc. Islam) because of marriage ,is he or she still catholic?
I am in RCIA and learned that though this is my first and only marriage, I married a divorced woman whose former husband was not faithful and was abusive both mentally and somewhat physically to her and their children. Am I not going to be able to partake of the sacrament of Eucharist when initiated?
Good morning Fr.
Thank you for your response to my question on Salvation. If I may add in a few more questions. What of those outside the Church? Those from other Christian denominations? They believe in Christ but I don’t think they would believe that Christ and the Catholic Church is THE WAY? And what about non-Christians; say a Hindu man who grew up in the interior regions of India who (through no fault of his own) has never seen an image of Christ or the Bible or even heard of Christ at all; and yet the man lives an almost holy life? what if the man dies; is he granted Salvation?
My Pa, who grew up in the Vatican I times; used to tell us; that good people who are not Catholics would go to a place called Limbo; is Limbo really another state of life? Are there any biblical backing to this theory? Does the Church still even teach this?
Oh and what about those who commit suicide; I understand that taking a life is a mortal sin which includes suicide; but say in a situation where a young catholic girl who has heard about heaven; that heaven is a good place; but you must die first before you get there; now this little girl only knows Jesus, Heaven and how to care for her wounds from the abuse she receives everyday; and at some point in her life; the abuse becomes too much; there is no one to turn to; everyone either thinks she’s a liar or an attention seeker; the pain is too much to bear; she is lonely; only one person can help her: Jesus, but Jesus is in Heaven; and to Heaven she must go. what happens in this situation? Will she be allowed a proper burial; does “Mass for the Dead” apply to her as well?
Dear Fr Joe,
Thanks alot for sparing your valuable time to give a detailed response to my question.
May the Sacred Heart of Jesus, in the most Blessed Sacrament, be praised, adored, and loved with grateful affection, in all the tabernacles of the world, and in the hearts of all men, even to the end of time. Amen
God bless you father and mother Mary protect you. Peace
Dear Fr Joe, Thanks for your blog. My question is whether a priest can deny someone communion for coming late to Mass. Today at a week day Mass it happened to a parishioner. Yes she was late I think she walked in at the beginning of the Eucharistic prayer. I just felt sad. I thought the most important thing is to receive holy communion in a state of grace. Also i think communion is sometimes given outside the celebration of Mass.
Please help me understand. Thanks. I appreciate your blog very much I am able to get spiritual enlightenment when I read your answers. God bless you Fr Joe. Much love and prayers.
Dear Fr. Joe, Thank you for the very discerning manner in which you assembled my three posts with questions about marriage and turned them into a single good post. You even left out something I said that was incorrect and was concerned about. Your answers were very helpful!
Even though I stated earlier that I would not post so often, I can’t help but respond to a post about the Holy Father. Some things the Holy Father has said recently about the Last Judgment have helped me very much. It has made me realize that I make life too complicated. All I need to do is to remain always faithful to Jesus Christ and live as the Church teaches me. I don’t recall if the Holy Father used this term but it helps me recall what Jesus said about the “pearl of great price.”
Thanks again Fr. Joe, and God Bless Our Pope!